The Water Efficiency Blogs

The Blogger

Elizabeth Cutright Water Efficiency Editor

More from this blogger

  1. Bridging the Gap
  2. Mind the Gap
  3. Back to School
  4. The Future of Southwest Water
  5. What medium for your message
  6. We (Might) Need a Bigger Boat
  7. Worst Case Scenarios
  8. Healthy Conservation
  9. Sustaining Supply
  10. Secret Handshake
  11. Second City Water
  12. Spills, Bills and Climate Change
  13. When Water and Energy Collide
  14. Blue Fever LEED
  15. Recycled Winter
  16. Energy Awareness
  17. Pollution and Source Protection
  18. Conveyance Catch Up
  19. Volume and Vintners
  20. Smithsonian Smarts
  21. Imbedded Industry
  22. Shake, Rattle, and Roll
  23. Low-Flow Hubris
  24. High Efficiency Plumbing
  25. Water Saving at the Corporate Level
  26. Reuse Wrap Up
  27. Household Water Use
  28. What's Your Waterprint
  29. Lawsuits, Pipelines, and One Tiny Fish
  30. One Million Acre-Feet
  31. Rainwater Ordinance
  32. Gauging Risks
  33. Batten Down the Hatches!
  34. WaterSense for New Homes
  35. Tri-State Co-Op
  36. What does a worst-case scenario look like
  37. All Bark and No Bite
  38. Subsidized Water
  39. Keeping It Local
  40. Private or Public
  41. What's Your Standard
  42. WE Professionals Take a Bow
  43. Pipe Bursts, News at 11
  44. Drought, Demand, and the GW Bogeyman
  45. Smart Water Use
  46. Delta Update
  47. Alternative Sources
  48. Water Saved Is Water Earned
  49. Mile-High Metering
  50. Smart Water Grid
  51. Seeing Into the Future
  52. Can Two Rights Make a Wrong
  53. Thinking Big, Going Small
  54. The Dead Zone
  55. Pipe Dreams
  56. Interdependency
  57. Low-Tech Leak Detection
  58. Money-Management Musical Chairs
  59. A First for Rainwater Harvesting
  60. Purpose and Intent
  61. Drought Dangers
  62. All Eyes on the West
  63. Climate Chaos
  64. Preemptive Strike
  65. A Place With No Meters
  66. Water Buffaloes in the Delta
  67. Wildfires and Water Conservation
  68. National Drinking Water Week
  69. Finally Teamwork
  70. Tainted Water
  71. Hit them in the pocketbook!
  72. The Place to Be
  73. Where the WE's Are
  74. Let's Be Friends
  75. Free Market Water
  76. Role Model
  77. Budget Basics
  78. Breaking It All Down
  79. Unsung Heroes
  80. It's Raining, It's Pouring..
  81. Meter Management
  82. Finding Funding
  83. Turning Lemons Into Lemonade
  84. New Rules for a New Year
  85. Is it a water grab or a reasonable solution
  86. Drops and Crops
  87. Dear Santa..
  88. Not Just Storm Clouds on the Horizon
  89. Wondering After a Winter Break
  90. Virtual Water
  91. Water and Compromise
  92. Reuse Revisited
  93. Turf Revisited
  94. Taking it to the Next Level
  95. The Nine Steps
  96. Water Lemons
  97. To Turf or Not to Turf
  98. News You May Have Missed
  99. The Wall Street Ripple Effect
  100. Let it Rain!
  101. Another Perspective
  102. De-Centralizing
  103. Personal Responsibility Versus Government Action
  104. Field Trippin' in the Garden
  105. Grand Theft Water
  106. Drowning Dragon
  107. Money Changes Everything
  108. Sharks! Tomatoes! Astroturf!
  109. Titans of Industry - Should Big Business Control The Tap
  110. Welcome to the New Site!
view all

WE Editor's Blog

December 21st, 2009 12:33pm PST

Nuclear Desalination

Posted By Elizabeth Cutright 2 Comments

We’ve talked a lot about the connection between energy and water, but here’s another perspective courtesy of Telegraph UK.  In a commentary posted in the Finance section, Commodities Editor Garry White discusses the possibility that switching to nuclear energy could help solve our water crisis. White points to the Middle East as an example of how countries like UAE (which will see it's electricity demand double by 2020) and Saudi Arabia (which is already planning to use nuclear power for 25% of its electricity needs) are looking to nuclear power as the best way to meet their future power demands. While it's true that nuclear energy will reduce dependence on fossil fuels, there is—as White points out—an added benefit: Nuclear reactors not only generate electricity, they can also desalinate water.

In fact, nuclear desalination is already being used successfully in Kazakhstan, where one nuclear reactor sits on the shore of the Caspian Sea. During that reactor's lifespan (1972–1999), it produced 135 MW of electricity and 80,000 cubic meters of potable water every day. And nuclear desalination is not confined to the middle east—Japan and India are both using nuclear reactors to desalinate water.  

So what do you think? Desalination in general is energy intensive, so does pairing it up with nuclear power make it a more viable option? And although nuclear power reduces dependence on fossil fuels—and as a result contributes to a reduction in greenhouse gas emissions—does that benefit outweigh the risks? And is this just a niche solution suitable for only certain hard-pressed environments (like the Middle East), or could nuclear desalination make sense for any coastal region?

What Do You Think?

Post a Comment

wliebold@dep.nyc.gov

December 23rd, 2009 7:23 AM PT

Kazakhstan is not the best example to use if you're trying to construct an argument for nuclear plant-based desalination. Soviet plants ran with safety systems and proecures that are not equal to those in most "western" countries. Your claim that the plant produced "potable" water should not be accepted without independent supporting data. If we proceed with using nuclear power plants for desal, the bottled water industry certainly will be happy. Desal would require at least another set, and possibly two sets of heat exchangers between the reactor's secondary system and the water being boiled for desal. I say two because reactor steam generators continue to have at least minor leak problems which contaminate the secondary system. While the argument that such leaks are too minor to have any health impact outside or even within the containment or turbine buildings may be valid, they will probably be unacceptable to drinking water consumers.

jimkelleysierra

December 22nd, 2009 8:33 PM PT

Nuclear desalination does make sense and has been used in coastal nuclear plants in California. In the long run, however, solar will be the best solution worldwide, since dry places usually have lots of sunshine and eventually the capitla investment will be much lower than building nuclear plants when thin film technologies take over from PV and RO systems become Forward Osmosis systems.

Post a Comment

Not a subscriber? Sign Up
 
 
*